How Do Traffic Tickets Affect Insurance Rates?

The Number of Demerit Points that a Traffic Ticket Presents is Irrelevant to Insurance Rating Systems. A Traffic Ticket May Affect Insurance Rates Because of the Type or Category of Violation. Accordingly, Indirectly it May Appear That There is a Correlation Between Demerit Points and Insurance Rates.

Understanding How Traffic Ticket Convictions Affect Automobile Insurance Premium Rating Systems

Police Chasing Blue Sports Car The ways for which a traffic ticket charge may result in consequences upon conviction of the person charged can be complex and confusing and are often misunderstood. Misunderstanding often occurs due to a general misunderstanding about how automobile insurance rating is performed.  To gain a better grasp about how a conviction for a traffic charge may result in automobile insurance rate consequences, understanding how the automobile insurance rating system works is necessary.

Formulaic Processes

Rates are calculated in a rather complex formulaic process based on a myriad of factors rather than simply as an arbitrary figure.  Essentially, an insurance broker, insurance agent, or insurance underwriter, works through a number of variables to determine various categories and rankings which are then used to find the corresponding rate, for each section of coverage, such as liability, collision, etc. The various sections of coverage include items such as liability, accident benefits, collision, etc.  The calculations for each coverage are then added up to become the total premium, meaning price, of the automobile insurance.  Of course, with technology of today, the calculations are done using computers are and done in moments; however, in the past automobile insurance rating was done by hand and today, for some circumstances, such as the rating of commercial automobiles, among others, calculations are still sometimes done without the help of computers.

Rating Classification Basics
Purpose of Vehicle

Typically, before the driving record of a person is applied within an automobile insurance rating system, the classification categories for both the driver and the vehicle are first determined.

For many insurance companies, a classification of '01' is used for a driver, male or female, over twenty-five (25) years of age, who drives for personal use, meaning without commuting to a workplace or driving for business.  With many insurance companies, a person, again over twenty-five (25) years of age, who commutes a short distance to work, falls within the '02' classification.  Depending on the insurer, there can be more than a dozen driver classifications.  For commercial automobile insurance, the possible categories are based on the use of the vehicle rather than the driver specifics; and accordingly, the classification could be classification '43' for a delivery van or classification '47' for a logging truck.

Nature of Vehicle

For vehicle categorizations, meaning the character of the vehicle rather than the use of the vehicle, the classifications generally have three digits, each between one and five.  The first digit relates to the liability risk factors involving how frequently and how severely the vehicle is involved in a third party liability case.  The second digit relates to the risk factors involving statutory accident benefits coverage and how frequently and how severely the vehicle is involved in this circumstance.  The third digit relates to the risk factors involving damage to vehicle itself and how frequently and how severely the vehicle incurs damage claims.  Understanding these factors, one might imagine that a family mini-van would pose a lower risk of liability, accident benefits, and damage, than would a small high powered sports car.  Accordingly, a family minivan may be classified as '02/03/10' while a the sports car may be classified as '04/05/30' which represents, statistically, a higher risk in all three concerns.

Driving Record

The above rating basics are, as yet, without direct regard to the experience of drivers as intended vehicle operators.  However, once the vehicle classifications for both the use or purpose of the vehicle is known as well as the nature of the vehicle itself, factors relevant to the drivers are categorized.  Generally, the higher the number reflecting a driving record, the more experienced, and accident free, a driver is and thus the lower insurance premiums will be.  Traditionally, the driving record scale ranged from zero to six; however, some insurers now use an extended range.  Regardless, the traditional expression 'six-star' driver remains common and is in reference to a driver that has climbed to the top of the driving record scale provided by the respective insurer.  The driving record scale, metaphorically, can be perceived as a ladder where a driver climbs a rung every year that the driver is licensed, insured, and remains accident free.  A driver with an at-fault accident that occurred three years prior to the most recent insurance renewal will be referred to as a 'three-star' driver.  A driver with an at-fault accident that occurred four years prior to the most recent insurance renewal will be referred to as a 'four-star' driver.  And so forth.

Contrary to common urban myth belief, an insurance driving record is without any direct affect by demerit points as may be assigned by the Ministry of Transportation due to a traffic ticket conviction.  The driving record may be affects by traffic ticket convictions; however, the demerit points are irrelevant.

Underwriting Acceptance Guidelines

Insurance companies will have rules, being underwriting guidelines, governing the characteristics of acceptability for insurance.  Only those persons meeting the underwriting criteria of a particular insurance company will be offered insurance coverage.  Additionally, similar to the formality of the rating methods, the underwriting criteria is formal rather than arbitrary.  Furthermore, insurance companies may receive large fines for failing to follow the underwriting criteria whereas each insurer is required to file the underwriting criteria along with the rating tables with the Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario as the regulator of insurance companies, among other things.

Conviction Surcharges

After all of the above, so long as a driving record meets the underwriting guidelines of the insurance company being applied to, otherwise the driver is disqualified from obtaining insurance with that insurance company and therefore everything else is moot, review of traffic ticket convictions for the purpose of calculating surcharges, if any, occurs.  Again, most of this happens electronically by computer; however, in the past, these calculations were made manually by an insurance agent, insurance broker, or underwriter, while reviewing the insurance company rating manual (book).

Generally, as each insurer may have variations, a single minor traffic ticket conviction, such as a speeding ticket of less than fifteen (15) km over the limit, results in zero surcharge.  Two minors may result in a ten (10%) percent, or more, surcharge.  A single major conviction, such as speeding between thirty (30) km and forty-nine (49) km over the limit may result in a fifteen (15%) percent to twenty-five (25%) percent surcharge.  Serious convictions, such as a careless driving conviction present as a fifty (50%) percent surcharge; however, a careless driving charge will likely appear even higher.  The reason a careless driving conviction may appear as more than a fifty (50%) percent surcharge is that the presence of a careless driving conviction is usually enough to disqualify a driver from insurance companies within the regular marketplace.  Accordingly, the driver with a careless driving conviction incurs the affects of purchasing insurance from a high-risk insurer plus the application of a fifty (50%) percent surcharge to the high-risk rates.  The net result may be a a doubling, or more, in the insurance premiums the driver paid to a regular market insurer prior to the careless driving conviction.  If an accident occurred in connection to the careless driving conviction, the net result to insurance premiums may even go beyond tripling and even further for novice drivers or drivers with a multitude of convictions.

Traffic ticket convictions remain on the record used by insurance companies for three years and may affect insurance rates during this time.  After the conviction falls off the record, insurers are forbidden from reviewing or considering such 'older' convictions.

Summary Comment

Insurance rating systems are very complex and while there are general concepts, some of which are identified above, every insurer and every person will have unique characteristics.  Accordingly, the above is provided for general information purposes only.  For a better, proper, and qualified, understanding of how insurance rating systems work, especially how you fit into the rating system of your own specific insurance company, contact your insurance agent or insurance broker.

Avoid Increased Insurance Rates.
Start Your Traffic Ticket Fight Today.

Need Help?Let's Get Started Today

ATTENTION: Do not send any confidential information through this web form.  Use this web form only to make an introduction.

Send a Message Directly to KLP Paralegal Services

ATTENTION: Confidential details about your case must not be sent through this website.  Use of this website does not establish a legal-representative/client relationship.  Do not include confidential details about your case by email or phone.  Use this website only for an introduction with KLP Paralegal Services. 
Privacy Policy & Cookies | Terms of Use Your IP Address is:
KLP Paralegal Services
Professional Corporation

Unit 600, The East Mall, PO 11577
Toronto, Ontario,
M9B 4B1

P: (416) 570-6378
F: (905) 629-8630


9:00AM – 5:00PM
9:00AM – 5:00PM
9:00AM – 5:00PM
9:00AM – 5:00PM
9:00AM – 5:00PM

By appointment only.  Call for details.
Messages may be left anytime.

Sign Up